Carter Hart’s Second Chance Dilemma
The NHL’s recent decision to reinstate five Team Canada players, acquitted of serious charges earlier this summer, has ignited a heated debate. Opinions split sharply between those advocating for second chances and those who believe it would be best for these players to remain sidelined. As the landscape shifts, these players will be eligible to sign contracts starting in October, and should they find teams, they can take to the ice as early as December 1.
The Players in Focus
While Alex Formenton has opted to take his talents overseas, the remaining quartet—Cal Foote, Dillon Dube, Michale McLeod, and Carter Hart—are navigating the next phase of their careers. Among them, goaltender Carter Hart is drawing significant attention, especially with speculation linking him to the Edmonton Oilers. However, mixed reports have emerged regarding the team’s interest in signing him.
Evaluating the Risk and Reward
Hart could undoubtedly provide a boost to the Oilers’ goaltending depth, which currently includes Stuart Skinner and Calvin Pickard. However, the question looms: is the potential contribution worth the backlash that may accompany his signing? The controversy surrounding Hart could alienate fans, posing a dilemma for the franchise. Edmonton must consider whether the benefits of his talent outweigh the risks of community backlash.
Time Away from the Game
Adding another layer to this situation is Hart’s absence from the league for two years. While he has remained dedicated to his fitness regimen, the challenge of integrating back into the NHL after such a lengthy hiatus cannot be underestimated. Hart’s career statistics reflect both promise and struggle, with a record of 96 wins, 93 losses, and 29 overtime losses, alongside a 2.94 goals-against average and a .906 save percentage—all accrued during his tenure with the Philadelphia Flyers, who drafted him 48th overall in 2016.
Alternative Options for Edmonton
The Oilers have other goaltending options on the table, including James Reimer, Ilya Sorokin, and potential trades for players like Anthony Stolarz or Jordan Binnington. Given these alternatives, pursuing Hart may signal desperation during a pivotal time for the franchise.
The Future of Carter Hart
As speculation continues, the future remains uncertain for Hart. Will he secure a position with a team willing to overlook the surrounding controversy? For Edmonton, taking a chance on Hart might not be the most prudent course of action, and only time will reveal what lies ahead for the embattled goaltender.
