Cale Makar vs Quinn Hughes: A Debate on the NHL’s Elite Defensemen
Cale Makar and Quinn Hughes are undeniably the two premier defensemen in the NHL today. Both players have established themselves as superstars, showcasing their incredible skills and impact on the ice. As they navigate through the primes of their careers, the debate over who stands as the top defenseman in the league intensifies.
Makar’s Stellar Resume
With just six seasons in the professional ranks, Makar has already carved out an impressive legacy. The Colorado Avalanche star is often regarded as the consensus choice for the best blue-liner in hockey, and for good reason. His ability to influence games with his offensive prowess and defensive capabilities has set a high bar for others in the league.
The Case for Hughes
However, the conversation does not end with Makar. Many analysts and fans point to a remarkably close comparison between him and Hughes. Some argue that Hughes, the captain of the Vancouver Canucks, is not only a formidable competitor but perhaps the more complete player overall. Canucks reporter Harman Dayal is one such voice in this debate, asserting a strong case for Hughes’s superiority.
Dayal’s Insights on the Competition
During a recent episode of the Canucks Conversation Podcast, Dayal expressed his evolving perception of the two defensemen. “The more I watch Cale Makar, the more convinced I am that Quinn Hughes is better than him,” Dayal remarked. He emphasized that true appreciation for each player’s skill requires watching them in full games consistently.
Dayal highlighted Hughes’s unique ability to drive offensive plays and facilitate zone exits independently—a skill he believes Makar may not need to demonstrate as frequently due to the talent surrounding him in Colorado. “I guarantee you if Makar and Hughes switched spots, Hughes would put up the same totals that Makar did, but Makar couldn’t do what Hughes does, I think, all by himself,” he added, underscoring his belief in Hughes’s capabilities.
A Growing Debate
As the NHL season unfolds, the debate surrounding Makar and Hughes will only gain momentum. Both players bring distinctive talents to their teams, and their performances will be closely scrutinized by fans and analysts alike. With every game, the question of who reigns supreme as the top defenseman in the league will continue to fuel discussions, adding an intriguing layer to the 2023-2024 NHL season.
