Vikings face uncertainty as J.J. McCarthy’s concussion paves the way for Max Brosmer’s potential debut
The Minnesota Vikings find themselves in a challenging situation following J.J. McCarthy’s entry into the concussion protocol after a tough loss to the Green Bay Packers. This development sets the stage for backup quarterback Max Brosmer, who may be poised to make his NFL starting debut this weekend against the Seattle Seahawks, led by quarterback Sam Darnold and sporting an impressive 8-3 record.
Brosmer’s Rise to Backup Quarterback
Brosmer has served as the Vikings’ backup for much of the season, initially stepping in behind either Carson Wentz or McCarthy. This season’s journey took a turn when McCarthy suffered a high ankle sprain in Week 2, sidelining him for five games. Brosmer’s opportunity arose further when Wentz was placed on season-ending injured reserve after Week 8 due to a shoulder injury.
Head coach Kevin O’Connell confirmed on Monday that Brosmer will take first-team reps during McCarthy’s absence. O’Connell stated, “It’s probably too early to tell” who would start at quarterback, emphasizing a cautious, day-by-day approach to McCarthy’s recovery. “It’s a medical thing, first and foremost,” he added, indicating that the team’s decision will hinge on McCarthy’s progress through the protocol and the preparation time available.
The Likelihood of Brosmer’s First Start
While McCarthy’s recovery remains uncertain, the likelihood of Brosmer making his first career start this Sunday appears strong. Typically, players miss at least one game when entering the concussion protocol. Even if McCarthy shows improvement later in the week, O’Connell might be hesitant to rush him back, especially given McCarthy’s recent struggles. The focus will be on ensuring the quarterback is fully prepared before taking the field again.
Max Brosmer’s Background and Skills
Brosmer brings a wealth of experience to the Vikings, having spent five years at the University of New Hampshire, where he led the FCS level in passing yards in 2023. After a medical redshirt and an additional year of COVID eligibility, he transferred to the University of Minnesota for his sixth year in 2024. During his time with the Gophers, Brosmer completed nearly 67 percent of his passes, throwing for 18 touchdowns against six interceptions while also rushing for five scores, contributing to an 8-5 season.
O’Connell first took note of Brosmer at the Gophers’ Pro Day in 2024, even before he played a snap for the team. His evaluation continued at Minnesota’s Pro Day earlier this year. After going undrafted in April, Brosmer remained in Minnesota, signing with the Vikings as a priority undrafted free agent.
Throughout the offseason, Brosmer received praise for his rapid assimilation of the Vikings’ offensive system. His strengths lie in his processing ability and his knack for delivering the ball with rhythm, akin to a point guard in basketball. This was evident during the Vikings’ preseason finale against the Tennessee Titans, where he completed 15 of 23 passes for 161 yards and a touchdown, showcasing his potential against starting defensive players.
Max Brosmer’s journey to an NFL debut is filled with promise, and as the Vikings navigate the uncertainty surrounding their quarterback situation, all eyes will be on him as he prepares to take the field against a formidable Seahawks team.
