San Francisco 49ers face pivotal decision on Trent Williams amid looming cap hit
As the offseason draws near, speculation regarding the future of Trent Williams with the San Francisco 49ers intensifies. While a separation seems improbable, the financial realities of the team’s salary cap situation could force difficult choices. With reports indicating that teams around the league are keeping an eye on Williams and his hefty contract, the 49ers have a significant decision to navigate.
The Cap Crunch
The looming cap hit of $38.8 million for the 2026 season stands as a major consideration for the 49ers. This figure ranks second highest on the team, trailing only pass rusher Nick Bosa’s $42 million. Bosa, at 28, is considered a cornerstone of the franchise and is unlikely to be moved. In contrast, Williams, who will enter free agency in 2027, has expressed a desire to continue playing possibly until the age of 40. This raises critical questions for the 49ers: Should they invest in a player who, while elite, is also aging? Should they simply accept the cap hit? Or contemplate a release or trade?
The Contract Details
Currently, Williams’ contract comprises a $22.2 million base salary along with a $10 million option bonus due on April 1. Given the current cap constraints, it is highly unlikely he will play under such a substantial cap hit next season. The 49ers are already facing challenges with their salary cap and will need to make strategic roster moves to enhance their competitiveness.
Exploring Options
While some analysts, like Jeremy Fowler, present the situation in stark terms—suggesting release or trade as the only viable options—there exists a more nuanced path forward. The 49ers could consider extending Williams’ contract. Although his age—37—might make this seem counterintuitive, the modern NFL allows teams to creatively manage cap hits through contract adjustments.
An extension could involve front-loading Williams’ deal with a signing bonus, providing him with immediate financial benefits while lowering the 2026 cap hit. This strategy would effectively extend his contract through 2026 and 2027, giving the team flexibility. Additionally, if they included void years, they could mitigate the cap impact for 2027.
The Financial Dynamics
The decision ultimately hinges less on the numerical cap hit and more on how much cash ownership is willing to allocate to Williams upfront. By providing significant cash now, the 49ers can smooth out cap hits in the following years. However, the team cannot manipulate the money already owed to the player.
Given Williams’ long-standing relationship with the organization, it is reasonable to expect that the team will pursue an extension rather than opting for a release. As the offseason approaches, the 49ers must weigh their options carefully, balancing financial prudence with the desire to retain a player of Williams’ caliber.
