McKivitz’s Contract Extension Proves Wise for 49ers
When the San Francisco 49ers decided to extend Colton McKivitz during the season, it sparked a conversation among fans and analysts alike. Some viewed the move as a gamble, questioning whether the team had truly made the right call. McKivitz had shown flashes of talent as a starting tackle, but inconsistency raised doubts about his long-term value. Fast forward to the present, and the 49ers appear to be reaping the rewards of that decision.
A Breakout Season for McKivitz
This season has marked a significant turning point for McKivitz. With only three sacks allowed thus far, his performance has been nothing short of impressive. Notably, the last sack he conceded came all the way back in Week 9. While Pro Football Focus (PFF) grades are just one way to evaluate player performance, McKivitz’s ranking among right tackles speaks volumes. He currently sits third overall, trailing only elite talents like Penei Sewell, Zach Tom, and Brian O’Neill.
His PFF metrics reveal a well-rounded game, as he ranks 12th in pass-block grade among right tackles and impressively stands second overall in run-blocking, with Sewell as the sole player ahead of him. McKivitz’s development as a run blocker is particularly noteworthy, considering he was not initially viewed as a strength in that area.
The Path to Success
To understand McKivitz’s growth, one must consider his journey through the NFL. In his first three seasons, he saw limited playing time. This gradual introduction to the professional game allowed him to acclimate, but it’s no surprise that he didn’t burst onto the scene immediately. His first substantial starting opportunity didn’t come until his fourth season, setting the stage for his current breakout.
Now in his sixth season, McKivitz has completed two full years as a starter and is thriving in what could be considered his peak performance. This trajectory aligns well with the expectations of a player in Kyle Shanahan’s intricate offensive system. During his initial season, McKivitz focused on mastering the offense, and by year two, he established himself enough for the 49ers to invest in him. Now, he is not just meeting but exceeding those expectations, effectively justifying the extension.
Future Implications for the 49ers
As McKivitz continues to excel, it positions the 49ers favorably for the future. With Trent Williams currently anchoring the left tackle position, the team is aware that a transition will eventually be necessary. However, McKivitz’s emergence means they may only need to address one tackle spot rather than two, providing them with much-needed flexibility in their roster planning.
Looking ahead to Week 16, McKivitz will face a formidable challenge against the Indianapolis Colts, who boast a strong defensive front led by breakout edge rusher Laitu Latu. If McKivitz can maintain his high level of play, the 49ers will have every reason to feel confident in their offensive line, knowing that their tackles can hold their own against any defensive duo.
In summary, the decision to extend Colton McKivitz is shaping up to be a shrewd move for the San Francisco 49ers. His development this season not only enhances his value but also strengthens the foundation of the team’s offensive line for years to come.

