Ryan Clark Critiques Colts’ Decision to Sign Philip Rivers
The Indianapolis Colts have turned to 44-year-old Philip Rivers to stabilize their quarterback situation after a turbulent season left their options dwindling. While a formal announcement is pending, it is widely anticipated that Rivers will be named the starting quarterback by head coach Shane Steichen. The decision has sparked mixed reactions, with some fans expressing excitement over Rivers’ return, while others, including former NFL safety Ryan Clark, have voiced strong objections.
Rivers’ Comeback Sparks Controversy
Clark didn’t hold back during an episode of First Take, labeling the Colts’ move as “incompetent” and “irresponsible.” He emphasized the significant risks involved in putting a veteran quarterback back on the field after a five-year hiatus from professional football, during which Rivers coached high school football. Clark pointed out that Rivers has always been a “stationary target” on the field, raising concerns about his ability to handle the pressures of a fast-paced NFL game, especially against formidable defenses like that of the Seattle Seahawks.
Clark articulated his doubts about Rivers’ readiness, saying, “Philip Rivers should not be starting this game.” He further noted that even if Rivers performs well or remains healthy during the season, it doesn’t change his stance on the decision. “I’m not going to retract this statement because it is a bad decision to put him out there,” Clark asserted.
Comparing Situations
In a striking comparison, Clark likened Rivers’ situation to that of Michael Jordan’s return to basketball after a lengthy break, arguing that Rivers lacks the same caliber of returnability. “This is not Michael Jordan coming back to play basketball after three years off for the Washington Wizards,” he stated, underscoring his belief that Rivers’ return does not carry the same weight or expectation.
As the Colts prepare for their upcoming season, the decision to rely on Rivers raises questions about the franchise’s long-term strategy and commitment to developing future talent. With the weight of Clark’s criticism hanging in the air, the Colts must navigate the complexities of their quarterback situation as they aim for a successful season ahead.

