Dolphins’ Offense Faces Challenges as Waddle Struggles to Fill Hill’s Absence
The Miami Dolphins are experiencing a significant shift in their offensive identity this season. Gone is the high-octane, pass-heavy approach that defined their play in 2022 and early 2023. Instead, the team has transitioned to a more balanced offensive scheme, marked by a reduced passing menu and an increased focus on the running game. However, this new approach has exposed a glaring issue: the Dolphins’ lack of a reliable second wide receiver (WR2).
Waddle Takes Center Stage
With Tyreek Hill sidelined for the remainder of the season due to an injury sustained against the New York Jets in Week 4, Jaylen Waddle has stepped up admirably into the WR1 role. He currently leads the team with 722 receiving yards. However, the drop-off in production following Waddle is troubling. Running back De’Von Achane ranks second on the team with just 370 receiving yards, highlighting the struggles of the passing game.
What’s even more concerning is that Hill, despite not playing since Week 4, still ranks third on the roster with a mere 265 receiving yards. This dependency on Waddle and short passes to Achane signals trouble for the Dolphins’ aspirations for a postseason run, regardless of how effective their ground game may become.
Underwhelming WR2 Options
The Dolphins’ options to support Waddle in the passing game are far from promising. Malik Washington is fourth in receiving yards with 234, but following him are three tight ends—Darren Waller, Julian Hill, and Tanner Conner—who have accumulated just 117, 91, and 91 yards, respectively. Waller, who is expected to be activated off injured reserve soon, has not played in four games. Hill primarily serves as a blocker, while Conner has lost his active roster spot.
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine, a free-agent acquisition that sparked optimism among fans and analysts alike, has underwhelmed with only 11 receptions on 19 targets for 89 yards this season. While he has contributed as a blocker, Westbrook-Ikhine was previously known as a vertical threat with the Tennessee Titans. That explosive potential seems to have vanished since his arrival in Miami.
The struggles of the passing game cannot be solely attributed to Westbrook-Ikhine. The Dolphins’ offensive scheme has lost its deep-threat capability, and Tua Tagovailoa’s regression exacerbates the situation.
Limited Solutions Ahead
As the Dolphins look for solutions, the options are limited. Washington might fit the mold of a receiver for this offense, but his route-running skills haven’t developed enough for Tagovailoa to trust him in critical situations. Waller, when healthy, has the ability to beat man coverage, but his history of injuries raises questions about his availability moving forward.
While this might seem like a minor issue, it poses a significant risk against stronger defenses. Miami’s upcoming opponents may not have the capability to exploit these weaknesses, but stiffer challenges loom on the horizon.
Looking to the Future at Receiver
As the season progresses, the Dolphins face a pressing need to address their receiving corps in the offseason. Currently, only Waddle, Washington, Westbrook-Ikhine, Hill, and Tahj Washington are under contract through 2026. However, Hill’s future with the team is uncertain, and even if he returns, he was showing signs of decline before his injury. Washington has proven to be an effective returner and gadget player, but he lacks the profile of a high-volume receiver.
To build a sustainable passing game, the Dolphins must seek to add another dynamic playmaker, whether through free agency or the draft. Recent mock drafts suggest the team could target Ohio State WR Carnell Tate with their 11th overall pick, reflecting the urgent need for talent in this area. Regardless of who is under center next season, the current group lacks the depth and skill to support a robust aerial attack.
