Miami Dolphins seek to dispel long-standing narratives in pivotal matchup with Pittsburgh Steelers
The Miami Dolphins face a crucial test against the Pittsburgh Steelers on Monday night, a game that holds significant weight for their slim playoff aspirations. Yet, this matchup transcends mere playoff implications; it’s a chance for the Dolphins to silence persistent narratives that have haunted the team since the arrival of head coach Mike McDaniel in 2022.
Challenging Conditions Await
As the Dolphins prepare to take on the Steelers in Pittsburgh, they brace for a chilly December evening. Historically, Miami has struggled in cold weather and against teams boasting winning records. However, this current iteration of the Dolphins has shown signs of evolution, particularly since their loss to the Baltimore Ravens in Week 9. The question looms: can this revamped Dolphins squad finally overcome the narratives that have plagued them?
Is Miami’s Offense Ready for the Cold?
The narrative that Miami, a team rooted in the warm climate of Florida, cannot perform in cold conditions is somewhat simplistic. The prevailing belief often centers on the temperature affecting the Dolphins’ offensive capabilities. Yet, the true challenge has been the wind, which has hindered their passing game in the past.
Under McDaniel and quarterback Tua Tagovailoa, the Dolphins initially relied heavily on the passing game. Tua’s physical limitations made it difficult for him to navigate windy conditions effectively. However, this season marks a shift. Miami has transformed into a run-first offense, featuring standout performances from De’Von Achane and an improving offensive line. Over the past four games, the Dolphins have consistently rushed for over 160 yards.
Achane’s status for this game remains uncertain, but even if he is limited, Miami has demonstrated its ability to run the ball effectively with backs like Jaylen Wright and Ollie Gordon. The key to their offensive success this season lies in their strategic approach to running the ball. Miami has embraced heavier formations, incorporating six offensive linemen and traditional tight ends, reducing the reliance on running backs. This new strategy enhances their ability to attack defenses, making them more versatile and better suited for the unforgiving conditions of winter football.
Among the narratives weighing on the Dolphins, their ability to handle cold weather is one they seem more equipped to confront than in previous seasons.
Can the Dolphins Compete Against Winning Teams?
The Dolphins’ enhanced offensive strategy plays a significant role in their potential competitiveness. Yet, there remains skepticism about their ability to perform against formidable opponents. Miami’s recent record against winning teams is troubling: they have only managed a 3-15 mark over the last three seasons, with just one victory this year.
Despite winning five of their last six games, those victories came against teams struggling in the standings, including the Atlanta Falcons and New York Jets. Furthermore, the quarterbacks faced during this stretch have largely been backups, with the exception of Josh Allen. This lack of competition raises doubts about the Dolphins’ readiness to tackle stronger teams.
Compounding this is the fact that Miami’s passing game has regressed. While running the ball becomes increasingly important as the season progresses, the Dolphins will need to rely on their passing attack to secure victories. Currently, their aerial game lacks the potency it once had.
However, there is a silver lining. The Steelers, currently at 7-6, are not a dominant force. Their defense has struggled, particularly with the absence of star linebacker T.J. Watt, who is recovering from surgery for a collapsed lung. Meanwhile, Pittsburgh’s offense has its own limitations, particularly with Aaron Rodgers at the helm.
Looking ahead, the Dolphins face a schedule that offers potential opportunities. Their next opponents include the Cincinnati Bengals, who are not currently above .500, and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, who recently dropped to 7-7. The only truly formidable challenge remaining is against the New England Patriots, who boast an impressive 11-2 record. Yet, divisional rivalries can often produce unpredictable outcomes.
A Path to Redemption
With the Dolphins’ new offensive identity and a defense that has shown improvement, there is a credible path for Miami to dispel the narratives surrounding them. However, those narratives will only be fully extinguished through tangible results on the field.
As the Dolphins prepare for their prime-time clash against the Steelers, they will have their first opportunity to confront these narratives head-on. Whether this moment marks a turning point for Miami remains to be seen, but the stakes have never been higher.

