49ers urged to start rookie Connor Colby over veteran Bartch amid lineup shakeup for potential offensive boost
The San Francisco 49ers are facing a pivotal decision regarding their starting offensive line, particularly at the left guard position. With the season underway, the question of whether to stick with veteran Ben Bartch or to elevate rookie Connor Colby has become more pressing.
Bartch’s Struggles and Injuries
Bartch, who came into the season having barely secured his starting role, has had a tumultuous tenure with the 49ers. Over the past two seasons, he has only managed two starts, raising questions about his reliability. His limited performance in training camp, compounded by injuries that kept him sidelined for much of the summer, has not helped his case. While Bartch eventually returned to the field, the competition for the starting spot had evolved; Spencer Burford emerged as a formidable swing tackle, and Nick Zakelj played himself out of contention.
Colby, a seventh-round draft pick, has seized the opportunity presented by Bartch’s injury. His ability to step in and perform during preseason games has impressed coaches and fans alike. After Bartch suffered an injury early in Week 2, it was Colby who showcased his skills, demonstrating a commendable run-blocking ability and proving he could hold his own against starting defenses.
Colby’s Promising Development
The coaching staff’s decision to give Colby significant playing time was a strategic move that is now paying dividends. The 22-year-old rookie has not only demonstrated his readiness to compete but has also shown an upside that Bartch, at 27 years old, may not possess. Colby’s performance has been marked by moments of brilliance, and while he has had his share of rookie challenges, he has not appeared out of place among seasoned players.
The contrast between the two players is stark. Bartch’s history of limited impact in his six seasons—24 starts total, with only four for the 49ers—suggests a player who may have reached his ceiling. Meanwhile, Colby’s trajectory is on the rise. As a rookie, he represents the potential for significant growth, which could elevate the offense as a whole.
Making the Switch
The decision to start Colby over Bartch is not merely a reflection of current performance, but also a forward-thinking strategy for the 49ers. With Bartch’s injury history and lack of significant contributions, it may be time for the coaching staff to pivot toward youth and potential. Colby has already proven he can handle the pressure of playing with the starters and should be given the opportunity to continue in this role.
As the 49ers navigate these lineup changes, keeping an eye on Bartch’s recovery will be crucial. However, the momentum appears to be favoring Colby as he continues to earn his place on the field. The 49ers’ offensive success may very well hinge on this decision, making it imperative that the coaching staff weighs all options carefully in the days to come.
