Contreras Trade Sparks Red Sox Lineup Reconfiguration
Willson Contreras, once celebrated as one of Major League Baseball’s top-hitting catchers, has made a significant position shift. After not donning the catcher’s gear for a single game this season, he transitioned to a full-time first baseman during his final year with the St. Louis Cardinals. On Monday, the Boston Red Sox welcomed Contreras via trade, a move that fans anticipate will provide a much-needed right-handed power bat. However, the question lingered: where exactly would he fit in the lineup?
Craig Breslow Weighs In on Contreras’ Role
In a press conference that followed the trade, Craig Breslow, the Red Sox’s chief baseball officer, clarified the team’s plans for Contreras. His comments suggested that the veteran’s days as a catcher in Boston would be extremely limited, if not entirely behind him.
“We’ll have those conversations,” Breslow stated during a Zoom call, as reported by MassLive. “But as of now, we see him primarily at first base, maybe some DH opportunities. The more that we can get his bat in the lineup, the better off we’re going to be.” He also commended Contreras for his smooth transition to first base, noting that he had improved defensively and had been rated as a well-above-average first baseman last season.
The Impact on Yoshida and Casas
With Contreras now in the fold, the dynamics of the Red Sox lineup have shifted, placing Triston Casas and Masataka Yoshida in uncertain positions. It’s clear that the trio of Contreras, Yoshida, and Casas cannot all occupy the first base and designated hitter roles simultaneously. Rumors have swirled around both Yoshida and Casas as potential trade candidates, casting doubt on their futures with the team.
Breslow did reassure fans that he had reached out to Casas, emphasizing the team’s belief in the young first baseman, who is still recovering from a torn left patellar tendon. Despite this encouragement, the reality remains that the Red Sox may not carry all three players into the season. One conceivable option is to start Casas in the minors, allowing him to prove he can once again dominate against major league pitching, reminiscent of his performance in the second half of 2023.
The next steps for the Red Sox will be crucial as they navigate these changes, trying to maximize the offensive potential that Contreras brings while managing the roster’s complexities.

