Mariners Eye Japanese Sluggers Amid Defensive Concerns
As the Seattle Mariners seek to bolster their offense for the upcoming season, attention has turned toward two prominent Japanese hitters: Munetaka Murakami and Kazuma Okamoto. The Mariners have a storied history of connecting with Japanese talent, highlighted by the legendary Ichiro Suzuki, who set the standard as Major League Baseball’s premier Japanese position player—at least until the emergence of Shohei Ohtani. This winter, both Murakami and Okamoto represent significant offensive potential as they transition to the U.S. market.
Scouts Raise Red Flags on Defensive Capabilities
However, recent insights from scouts have cast doubt on whether either player fits Seattle’s needs, particularly in terms of defense. Ryan Divish of the Seattle Times reported that scouts are largely skeptical about Okamoto and Murakami’s ability to handle third base at the major league level. With Josh Naylor recently securing a five-year, $92.5 million contract, the Mariners may find little incentive to pursue players who cannot reliably play third base.
“At first glance, both might seem like a fit since the Mariners have an opening at third base with Eugenio Suárez now a free agent,” Divish noted. “But after speaking with multiple professional scouts from opposing teams who have closely monitored both players over the past two seasons, the consensus is clear: neither Murakami nor Okamoto can project as viable options at third base due to defensive shortcomings. Both are better suited for first base.”
A Glimmer of Hope for Okamoto
Despite the prevailing skepticism, there remains a sliver of optimism for Okamoto. One scout expressed that he sees potential for Okamoto to adapt to playing third base, which could make him a more appealing option for the Mariners. As the older of the two sluggers at 28, Okamoto also offers a right-handed bat, contrasting with Murakami’s left-handed swing.
Navigating Financial Concerns
Given the financial implications of pursuing either player, the Mariners must tread carefully. With Okamoto projected to command nearly $100 million and Murakami expected to fetch an even higher price, Seattle faces a significant investment for a player whose defensive fit is anything but certain.
While the Mariners may not rule out the possibility of signing one of these talented hitters to fill a combination of roles—third base, first base, and designated hitter—the risk involved in such a gamble complicates their decision-making process. As they weigh their options, the Mariners are keenly aware that the right offensive addition could make a difference, but the question remains whether either of these Japanese stars can provide the desired defensive reliability alongside their offensive prowess.
