Pittsburgh Pirates make historic bid for Josh Naylor
The Pittsburgh Pirates, a team not often associated with aggressive free agency moves, shocked the MLB landscape with a bold attempt to sign first baseman Josh Naylor. Reports indicate that the Pirates made an impressive offer that would have represented the largest free-agent signing in the franchise’s history, a significant leap from their previous benchmarks.
Record-setting Potential
According to sources, the Pirates were prepared to extend a contract exceeding $78 million to Naylor, a figure that dwarfs their current record of $39 million, set in 2014 when they signed left-handed pitcher Francisco Liriano to a three-year deal. This ambitious offer underscored the franchise’s desire to bolster its roster and signal a shift in their approach to building a competitive team.
The Competition for Naylor
Despite the Pirates’ substantial offer, Naylor ultimately chose to remain with the Seattle Mariners, signing a five-year deal valued at $92 million. His decision highlights the challenges smaller-market teams often face in retaining or attracting top talent in a competitive landscape.
Addressing Offensive Challenges
The Pirates’ pursuit of Naylor stems from a pressing need to enhance their offensive capabilities. Last season, Pittsburgh struggled at the plate, finishing with the lowest slugging percentage (.350) and OPS (.655) in the league. Additionally, they recorded the fewest runs batted in (561) and home runs (117), leaving them at a disadvantage in a league that increasingly values power hitting.
As they look ahead to the upcoming season, the Pirates are clearly determined to revamp their lineup and pursue a playoff berth. While they may have missed out on Naylor, their willingness to make a historic bid suggests a newfound ambition that could reshape the future of the franchise.
In a league where financial resources often dictate success, the Pirates’ efforts to court Naylor reflect a larger narrative of growth and evolution within the organization, as they strive to compete with the best.

