Mets’ Jeff McNeil Sparks Trade Speculation Amid Recovery
The Oakland Athletics are in search of reinforcements at several positions, particularly second and third base. With the New York Mets facing questions about first base following Pete Alonso’s re-entry into free agency, last year’s A’s target, Brett Baty, seems to have faded from the radar. However, conversations are heating up surrounding aging second baseman Jeff McNeil, who is reportedly a significant trade asset for the Mets.
Surgical Setback and Recovery Timeline
The potential trade of McNeil is clouded by his recovery from thoracic outlet surgery. His agent has indicated optimism, suggesting that McNeil anticipates being ready for Spring Training. This timeline is crucial for both the Mets and any interested teams, including the Athletics, as they weigh the risks and rewards associated with acquiring a player in recovery.
A Versatile Asset for the Athletics
Last season, McNeil showcased his adaptability, appearing in 122 games across multiple positions: 79 at second base, 34 in center field, and even a handful of games at left and right field, along with designated hitter and first base duties. This kind of versatility could prove invaluable for the Athletics as they look to bolster their lineup.
At the plate, McNeil posted a .243 batting average with a .335 on-base percentage, hitting 12 home runs and achieving a 111 wRC+—a measurement that indicates his offensive production was 11% above league average. Throughout his career, McNeil has maintained a solid baseline at the plate, demonstrating the capacity to reach impressive heights, such as his 2019 performance where he was 44% above league average. His recent seasons have seen fluctuations in production, with wRC+ numbers of 140, 99, 97, and 111 respectively since 2022.
Consistency as a Core Value
A’s manager Mark Kotsay highlighted the importance of consistency in players when discussing the qualities that make a player invaluable around the trade deadline. Kotsay emphasized the need for reliable performance day in and day out, which is precisely what McNeil can offer when healthy. His veteran presence and predictable production could be just what the Athletics need to stabilize their roster and enhance their competitiveness in the coming season.
As the offseason unfolds, McNeil’s situation will be closely monitored, not only by the Mets but by teams like the Athletics looking to make meaningful upgrades. The convergence of his recovery timeline and trade discussions could set the stage for a notable offseason move.

