Astros Face Tough Decisions on Starting Rotation
As the offseason approaches, the Houston Astros find themselves at a crossroads regarding their starting rotation and bullpen. With Framber Valdez likely heading into free agency and Dylan Cease recently signing with the Toronto Blue Jays, the Astros will need to strategize how to bolster their pitching staff behind rising star Hunter Brown.
Lance McCullers Jr. Faces Uncertain Future
One player who seems unlikely to be part of the Astros’ future plans is right-handed pitcher Lance McCullers Jr. After spending time in the bullpen toward the end of the last season, it appears he will continue in that role as the team moves forward. McCullers’ inconsistent availability due to injuries over the past few years has raised concerns about his effectiveness and reliability.
A Contract Under Scrutiny
Entering the final year of his contract in 2026, McCullers is tied to a deal worth $85 million. This contract has drawn criticism, with some analysts labeling it one of the most unfavorable in Major League Baseball. Zachary D. Rymer pointed out that McCullers’ contract ranks among the top five worst for the upcoming season.
“Only during the 2021 season did the deal show signs of promise,” Rymer noted. In that year, McCullers made 28 starts, achieving a commendable 3.16 ERA while racking up 185 strikeouts across 162.1 innings. Had he entered free agency after that standout year, his market value would likely have soared past the $85 million mark.
Navigating the Pitching Landscape
As the Astros look to navigate their pitching landscape, the question remains: how will they manage McCullers’ situation moving forward? His track record and looming contract may complicate their efforts to build a competitive rotation. With the offseason unfolding, the Astros will need to weigh their options carefully, keeping an eye on both the present needs and future potential of their pitching staff.

