Jorge Polanco’s Surprising $42M Move to the Pittsburgh Pirates Stuns MLB Insiders
In the unpredictable realm of Major League Baseball free agency, certainty is a rare commodity. Teams often find themselves in a tug-of-war over players they cherish, only to see rivals swoop in with lucrative offers. Conversely, a stagnant market can bind a player to the team they were expected to leave. Such was the case last offseason for Jorge Polanco. After a challenging debut season with the Seattle Mariners, he opted for a modest one-year contract. However, he rebounded spectacularly, achieving a career-high 134 OPS+ during the regular season and delivering pivotal performances in October.
A Shift in Expectations
Fast forward to the current offseason, and the narrative has shifted once again. MLB Trade Rumors, known for its insightful predictions, has thrown a curveball into the mix, projecting Polanco’s next destination to be the Pittsburgh Pirates. This forecast has left many insiders raising their eyebrows, as it suggests a significant financial commitment from a franchise that has historically refrained from splurging on free agents.
Tim Dierkes from MLB Trade Rumors posited that Polanco could secure a three-year deal worth $42 million with the Pirates, indicating that the team might be looking to shake things up. The contributor noted, “A late deal to re-sign Polanco was originally met with skepticism, but Polanco turned back the clock with a terrific regular season and routinely played the hero as the Mariners’ season pushed all the way to Game 7 of the ALCS.”
Polanco’s Market Value
The Mariners’ decision not to issue a qualifying offer to Polanco has further fueled his market potential. This strategic move has undoubtedly opened doors for the second baseman, allowing him to explore opportunities that may not have been available otherwise. While two contributors from MLB Trade Rumors forecasted a return to Seattle for Polanco, others, like Steve Adams, speculated he might find a new home with the Kansas City Royals.
The Pirates’ New Direction
The Pirates have not signed a free agent to a multi-year deal since Ivan Nova in December 2016, a testament to their cautious approach in the free-agent market. However, whispers of a possible change in strategy are circulating. Polanco fits the profile of a player the Pirates could realistically target, especially given the uncertainties surrounding his potential.
As the offseason unfolds, all eyes will be on Pittsburgh, where Polanco’s unexpected signing could signify a new era for the Pirates. This move, if it comes to fruition, would not only be a substantial financial investment but also a statement that the team is ready to compete on a different level.

