Cardinals weigh tough decisions as Miles Mikolas’ future remains uncertain
As the St. Louis Cardinals embark on a pivotal offseason, a myriad of questions loom over the organization. Among these, the status of internal free agents is no longer a concern. The Cardinals made significant moves ahead of the trade deadline, parting ways with Ryan Helsley, Steven Matz, and Phil Maton—all of whom were pending free agents.
Mikolas’ Tenure with the Cardinals
With those trades complete, the Cardinals now face the reality that Miles Mikolas stands as the team’s sole free agent. Mikolas, who joined the organization prior to the 2018 season, has had a notable career in St. Louis, highlighted by two All-Star selections and a reputation as a reliable innings eater. However, the latter part of his tenure has been marked by inconsistency; he has not finished a season with an ERA below 4.78 since 2023.
Possible Return Sparks Debate
Despite his struggles, there remains a flicker of hope for a reunion. Mikolas has expressed interest in continuing his career with the Cardinals, particularly as the season drew to a close. MLB insider Mark Feinsand recently labeled a return “possible,” igniting discussions about whether the Cardinals should consider bringing back the veteran right-hander.
Evaluating the Decision Ahead
As the offseason unfolds, the Cardinals must carefully evaluate their options. The potential for Mikolas to return brings with it a complex web of considerations. His experience and familiarity with the team could be valuable, yet his recent performance raises questions about his effectiveness moving forward.
In a time of transition for the organization, the decision surrounding Mikolas will undoubtedly be one of the defining moments of this offseason for the Cardinals.
