Alek Manoah’s Unexpected Free Agency Opens Door for Blue Jays Reunion
The Toronto Blue Jays find themselves staring at an intriguing possibility: the return of Alek Manoah, a former All-Star and Cy Young finalist, now available after the Atlanta Braves non-tendered him. This decision, made public on Friday, allows the 27-year-old right-hander to explore free agency, reigniting discussions about his potential reunion with the team that drafted him.
Manoah’s Journey Through Injury and Setbacks
Manoah’s path has been anything but linear. Last season, he was on the mend from Tommy John surgery, working to reclaim his place in the game. However, the Blue Jays made the surprising move to designate him for assignment in late September, creating room on their 40-man roster. Despite the setback, Manoah showed resilience at Triple-A Buffalo, where he compiled a 1-1 record and a commendable 2.97 ERA over seven starts. His performance included 30 strikeouts against 18 walks in 33.1 innings, while limiting opponents to a .218 batting average.
The Braves, who acquired him, ultimately felt secure with their fifth starter options, leading to Manoah’s current free-agent status. This opens the door for a potential return to Toronto, a scenario that hinges on the sentiments lingering from his tumultuous tenure with the organization.
Highs and Lows in Toronto
Manoah’s journey with the Blue Jays was filled with both remarkable achievements and challenging obstacles. Drafted in the first round in 2019 from West Virginia, he made an immediate impact, debuting in the majors just two seasons later. His rookie campaign was impressive, posting a 9-2 record and a 3.22 ERA, earning him eighth place in the American League Rookie of the Year voting.
The following year, Manoah’s performance soared. He finished the 2021 season at 16-7 with a 2.24 ERA in 31 starts, striking out 180 batters while walking just 51 in 196.2 innings. His accolades included an All-Star selection, a spot on the All-MLB first team, and a third-place finish in AL Cy Young voting. At that moment, he was seen as a cornerstone for the franchise’s future.
However, the tide turned in 2023. Manoah struggled with control, ending the season with a disappointing 3-9 record and a 5.87 ERA over 19 starts. His decline led to a demotion to the minors as he sought to refine his mechanics. Unfortunately, he faced further turmoil, refusing to report to Triple-A Buffalo, which culminated in his season being cut short.
Toronto’s Roster Dynamics and Future Considerations
As the Blue Jays navigate their roster after recent tender deadline moves, they currently have 38 players on their 40-man roster, providing a potential opportunity for Manoah. They could extend him a Major League contract at the league minimum, offering him a chance at redemption in 2026.
The crucial question remains: is there mutual interest in rekindling this relationship? Both sides will need to weigh the past experiences and the potential for a fresh start. Manoah’s talent is undeniable, but the reconciliation of his past with the organization will be key in determining whether a reunion can materialize.
